Comparing Robert Frost’s “After Apple-picking” to “Apples” by Laurie Lee
I. Introduction
A. Opening
B. Thesis
i) By comparing After Apple-picking by Robert Frost and Apples, by Laurie Lee one can see how the poets coincidentally use similar subjects to illustrate a broader, more meaningful issue.
C. Plan
i) Subject
ii) Tone
iii)Style
II. Subject
A. Simple subjects=Larger message
B. Issue
i) Effect of man's interference with nature
ii) Same message, different points
a) message=man interfering with nature for his own gain leads to destruction
b) Frost
c) Lee
III. Tone
A. Tone reflects message
B. Frost
i) empty
ii) resigned
iii) like surrendering to an adversary
iv) man accepting that he has destroyed much of the environment and has harmed himself in doing so
C. Lee
i) warm
ii) peaceful
iii) like rolling with a gentle change
IV. Style
A. Style further enhances message
B. Frost
i) Narrative
a) detached/less emotional/man's carelessness toward nature
b) more directly factual
C. Lee
i) Descriptive
a) appreciative/emotional/beauty of nature functioning naturally
i) In Jude the Obscure, Thomas Hardy presents characters who violate the conventions of the repressive Victorian society while attempting to follow their natural instincts.
C. Plan
i) arouses sympathy in reader
ii) laughs with the character
II. Sympathy
A. Difference in values
i) present society is much more liberated
ii) we sympathize with characters when they’re persecuted for things which we don’t find unacceptable
iii) Hardy knew that would happen
a) pendulum
b) recognized his society was unreasonable
B. Jude (love)
i) society said you had to marry
ii) Jude and Sue
a) we sympathize because they act on impulses we accept and relate with
b) we sympathize when they’re punished
III. Laughing With The Character
A. Victorian customs regarding love
i) Jude and Sue laugh at the system.
ii) Hardy reveals how ridiculous he thinks it is through the characters (wedlock)
B.Sue and Jude’s happiness
i) Greek
a) Sue’s statues (she gets in trouble)
b) p. 365 Greek joyousness
c) in times of happiness, they can laugh at society